राखी बिड़लन को लाये थे ये सोच कर की वो आपकी दलिटाई का समर्थन करेगी पर वो तो तो आपको ही चुप करा गयी :)...वैसे उसकी आवाज मायावती की और च्छिच्छोरपन रखी सावंत के जैसा लगा...
Regarding your discussion on Banking Transaction Tax on 7th Jan, I would like to add to the discussion quoting the example of a salaried person having income of 12 Lacs.
As per the current tax structure, approx tax will amount to 2 Lacs considering the tax slabs.
If the banking transaction tax @ 2% is levied, total tax will be 24,000 Let's say he gives all the income to his family for spending, another 24,000 will have to be paid by the family. Total tax will still amount to 48,000, which is much less the amount of 2 lacs as per current tax structure.
Considering the fact, he might take a loan of Rs. 25,00,000 in the same year, an amount of Rs. 50,000/- will be added to his tax expenditure.
All the above transactions will add to total tax amounting to Rs. 98000/-, still cutting his over all taxes by 50%. A middle class man has to get credits (including Loans and his normal salary) amounting to Rs. 1 Crore (which is an exorbitant amount of transactions for a normal person) to pay same amount of tax as he pays on an income of Rs. 12 Lacs as per the current tax structure.
The essence of implementing Banking Transaction Tax coupled with calling back of high currency notes (Rs. 1000 and Rs. 500) lies in the fact that the parallel economy will have a setback. More money will start routing through bank accounts, since it wont be possible to make cash transactions because of small denominations available. To my mind, overall tax rate will be reduced, but the amount of money adding to our banking system will amount to higher collection of taxes.
Regarding the banking transaction tax debate, Ravish Ji please conduct this debate again with people who are willing to discuss the facts rather than empty rhetoric. I think this idea needs proper debate.
Jo comment main kar raha hoon wo yahan relevant nahi hai par aapke saamne prastut karna chahta tha aur ye hi jageh mili likhne ko
Banaras (my home town) me hui bhajpa ki ek rally me lagbhag 1.5 lakh log aye the..wahan stage pe shiv ji ki ek tasveer aur kuch varsh pehle hue bomb blast ki ek tasveer thi.. iske baad rajnath singh ji kehte hain "main ye nahi bolta ki har ek musalman aatankwadi hota hai..par main ye zaroor puchta hu ki har ek aatankwadi musalman kyu hota hai"(confer with source: Indian express)
Mera prashn: Relatively kam padhe likhe logo k saamne aise stage set karke aisi baatein bolna kya secularism hai?
main ye prashn islie kar raha hu ki maine namo ko padhe likhe logo k saamne bhaashan dete suna hai ki kya hindu kya musalman, sab bhaartiya hain.. matlab jagah badli to bhesh badal liya?
Source of the Varanasi rally information: Indian express
Hello Ravush Ji, Just finished watching today's prime time; I have been following you on TV from Ravish ki Report. I really have no clue on the taxation system but please try to avoid such topics like economic policy. It is just a request! Regards. Ashutosh Wadhwa
Hello Ravish jee You need to conduct the abolition of income tax debate again as this is very revolutionary idea. Prosenjit bose may consider this as laughing matter or in his words "mansik diwaliya pan" of bjp. But bjp is not the originator of this idea. You need to call arthakranti persons (mr rao was not given sufficient time) some noted echnomists, person with deep knowledge of existing taxation laws, some individuals from banking sector. The debate or discussion should be more on point rather than emotions. The pros and cons need to be discussed threadbare.
hi ravsh ji aapne 2 bar tax systew pe debate karaya. but aap dono din bilkul ektarafa rahe. jo log v naye system ki bat kar rahe the unki aapne ache se suni hi nhi..waise mai baba ka prasansak nhi hu but mujhe jo lga o mai bta rha hu..aap jaise anchor pe ye sab bate sobha nhi deta..kuch point mai apko batana chahta hu.maine ab tak ka sara prime time dekha hai jimse se mujhe 3 ache nhi lge. a) jab khap wale mudde pe debate chal rha tha. b) tax system ke dono episode. dono hi mudde bahut enteresting the but aap apna mind me result pahle se bana chuke the phir aap sawal puch rhe the..baki k muddo pe aapka debate bilkul hi aapke taraf se nutral rhta hai..last me aap kisi result pe pahuchte hai..waise mai bta du mai v khap k pakch me nhi hu..
1- aise debate me panelist ki sankhya kam honi chahiye. 2- sabki bato ko sunane ki koshish kare. 3- pahle se apne mind me perception mat banaye..
aap bol rhe the poor ko v utna hi tax dena padega aur rich man ko v utna hi dena padega.aap mujhe bataye koi agar hum saman( soap, cloth,petrol etc) kharidte hai tab v poor ko v utna me hi milta hai jitna ki rich ko..aur usme tax include rhta hai.. agar naya system aayrga to kewal receiving transaction pe tax lagega..aur ye sare tax khattam ho jayenge..
man lijiye koi apne bete k account me paise dale.. aur waha pe 2% tax cut gaya..ab agar uska beta wahi paisa nikal k market se kuch saman kharidta hai to ab use koi tax nhi dena padega chuki saman pe koi tax lagega hi nhi.. ye tha aapke dono dout ka answer..
waise mujhe is naye system k bare me kuch malum nhi hai..mai kewal aapke dout clear karne ki koshish kar rha tha..
ravish, baba k ek statement k karan aapko tax system me dimag khapana pad raha hai......pichhle do prime time me pahli baar aisa laga ki aapko koi sun hi nahi raha tha......ab baba ko kaun bataye ki bahut jyada bolna achha nahi hota......
sabne itna kuchh likha hai...plz ek reply to kijiye...
Maaf kijiyega par fir kahuga ki ye Transaction Tax wala concept bilkul bekar hai. Apne show jarur kiya, mere hisab se aapke aur hamare time ki barbadi thi. Ravish ke show ki kuch khasiyat hai, issues jo yaha uthte hai wo wakai me kuch ahmiyat rakhte hai. Phir bhi apne kiya, to shayad yahi soch ke kiya ho, is issue ke khokhale pan ko jara jana jaye.
सर आपने तो दिल पे ले लिया टैक्स को... काल्पनिक बातो से दूर रहिये... इतना तो बीजेपी भी न सोची होगी अभी तलक.. कमेटी भूल जाईये.. जो बीजेपी खुद सत्ता में होकर अपने बुनियादी मुद्दे मंदिर, ३७० पर कुछ नहीं कर सकी वो इतने जटिल टैक्स सिस्टम की ओर नज़र भी न डालने की, छेड़ना तो दूर की बात है..
किसीको क्या मिला ? बाबाजी का ठुल्लू!!
बड़ी निराशा हुई आपके पैनल के सवालो से बाबा से.. बिना देश की जटिलताओं को समझे बिना बाजार के रिश्ते समझे कोई कुछ भी बोल रहा और आप रोक नही पा रहे इतने बड़े अर्थशास्त्री होकर भी.. उम्मीद करता हूँ ऐसी बहस से आप भविष्य में बचेंगे..
bahut maaje hain TV media ke khadkarapp jaise intelligent ke ,,kabhi Babanomics, kabhi ball e bidlan,kabhi Bhukkal Nawab ,kabhi Rahul ki Maldives yatra ,kabhi Modi Saheb ki chai aur har waqt AAP
I am one consistent follower of your blog and show. Having said that, this is only the second time am adding a comment on your blog. As for rest of the times, I only enjoy listening to you and reading your blogs and have never felt the need to comment coz, when am listening to you or reading your blog, I feel as if am actually communicating to you.
So much for the emotions :). As far as the 'taxation' topic is concerned, I completely agree with what Mr. Saurabh Raj has mentioned in his comments and I do feel that we should give this approach a serious thought. Even Ramdev Ji was open for suggestions (he did talk about some slabs), and for once it is good that we're discussing around this topic.
(and yes, am a big fan of yours. Will make my day if I see a comment from you after my comment; even a smiley would do :P)
रवीश भाई, वेबसाइट का पता रोमन मे लिखा कीजिये, ऐसे भी आजकल हिंदी चैनल ऐसे शब्द जिनका हिंदी अनुवाद काफी सहजता से उपलब्ध है वैसे शब्दो के लिए भी अँग्रेज़ी प्रयोग करते है। arthakranti.org सही पता है ना कि अर्थक्रांतिओरजी, कुछ चैनल पे तो AAP को आप लिखते है :) BJP के बदले बीजेपी चलता है लेकिन कभी-कभी मतलब ही बदल जाता है।
चौटाला ने कुछ न किया हो,लेकिन किसानों व मज़दूर वर्ग के लिए काम अवश्य किये हैं । हज़ारों गाँव के बच्चों को नौकरियाँ दी । सरकार आपके द्वार प्रोग्राम के तहत ब्लॉक स्तर पर लोगों से रूबरू होते थे । बतौर वर्कर कई साल मेहनत की, विकलाँग होते हुए भी, हमेशा गाँव में लोगों के बीच रहे । सादा खानपान, कभी शराब व बीडी सिगरेट का सेवन नहीं किया, साधारण पहनावा । 19 महीने, ऐमरजैंसी के दौरान जेल में रहे... कुछ तो किया था ।
boring...
ReplyDeleteराखी बिड़लन को लाये थे ये सोच कर की वो आपकी दलिटाई का समर्थन करेगी पर वो तो तो आपको ही चुप करा गयी :)...वैसे उसकी आवाज मायावती की और च्छिच्छोरपन रखी सावंत के जैसा लगा...
ReplyDeleteHi Ravish
ReplyDeleteRegarding your discussion on Banking Transaction Tax on 7th Jan, I would like to add to the discussion quoting the example of a salaried person having income of 12 Lacs.
As per the current tax structure, approx tax will amount to 2 Lacs considering the tax slabs.
If the banking transaction tax @ 2% is levied, total tax will be 24,000
Let's say he gives all the income to his family for spending, another 24,000 will have to be paid by the family. Total tax will still amount to 48,000, which is much less the amount of 2 lacs as per current tax structure.
Considering the fact, he might take a loan of Rs. 25,00,000 in the same year, an amount of Rs. 50,000/- will be added to his tax expenditure.
All the above transactions will add to total tax amounting to Rs. 98000/-, still cutting his over all taxes by 50%. A middle class man has to get credits (including Loans and his normal salary) amounting to Rs. 1 Crore (which is an exorbitant amount of transactions for a normal person) to pay same amount of tax as he pays on an income of Rs. 12 Lacs as per the current tax structure.
The essence of implementing Banking Transaction Tax coupled with calling back of high currency notes (Rs. 1000 and Rs. 500) lies in the fact that the parallel economy will have a setback. More money will start routing through bank accounts, since it wont be possible to make cash transactions because of small denominations available. To my mind, overall tax rate will be reduced, but the amount of money adding to our banking system will amount to higher collection of taxes.
P.S. : I love your show 'Prime Time' on NDTV.
Thanks for reading the message. :)
Regarding the banking transaction tax debate, Ravish Ji please conduct this debate again with people who are willing to discuss the facts rather than empty rhetoric. I think this idea needs proper debate.
ReplyDeleteThanks
aaj ka prime time nirashajanak raha.
ReplyDeleteHello Sir
ReplyDeleteJo comment main kar raha hoon wo yahan relevant nahi hai par aapke saamne prastut karna chahta tha aur ye hi jageh mili likhne ko
Banaras (my home town) me hui bhajpa ki ek rally me lagbhag 1.5 lakh log aye the..wahan stage pe shiv ji ki ek tasveer aur kuch varsh pehle hue bomb blast ki ek tasveer thi.. iske baad rajnath singh ji kehte hain "main ye nahi bolta ki har ek musalman aatankwadi hota hai..par main ye zaroor puchta hu ki har ek aatankwadi musalman kyu hota hai"(confer with source: Indian express)
Mera prashn:
Relatively kam padhe likhe logo k saamne aise stage set karke aisi baatein bolna kya secularism hai?
main ye prashn islie kar raha hu ki maine namo ko padhe likhe logo k saamne bhaashan dete suna hai ki kya hindu kya musalman, sab bhaartiya hain.. matlab jagah badli to bhesh badal liya?
Source of the Varanasi rally information: Indian express
Student, IIT Delhi
Hello Ravush Ji,
ReplyDeleteJust finished watching today's prime time; I have been following you on TV from Ravish ki Report. I really have no clue on the taxation system but please try to avoid such topics like economic policy. It is just a request!
Regards.
Ashutosh Wadhwa
Hello Ravish jee
ReplyDeleteYou need to conduct the abolition of income tax debate again as this is very revolutionary idea. Prosenjit bose may consider this as laughing matter or in his words "mansik diwaliya pan" of bjp. But bjp is not the originator of this idea. You need to call arthakranti persons (mr rao was not given sufficient time) some noted echnomists, person with deep knowledge of existing taxation laws, some individuals from banking sector. The debate or discussion should be more on point rather than emotions. The pros and cons need to be discussed threadbare.
hi ravsh ji
ReplyDeleteaapne 2 bar tax systew pe debate karaya. but aap dono din bilkul ektarafa rahe. jo log v naye system ki bat kar rahe the unki aapne ache se suni hi nhi..waise mai baba ka prasansak nhi hu but mujhe jo lga o mai bta rha hu..aap jaise anchor pe ye sab bate sobha nhi deta..kuch point mai apko batana chahta hu.maine ab tak ka sara prime time dekha hai jimse se mujhe 3 ache nhi lge.
a) jab khap wale mudde pe debate chal rha tha.
b) tax system ke dono episode.
dono hi mudde bahut enteresting the but aap apna mind me result pahle se bana chuke the phir aap sawal puch rhe the..baki k muddo pe aapka debate bilkul hi aapke taraf se nutral rhta hai..last me aap kisi result pe pahuchte hai..waise mai bta du mai v khap k pakch me nhi hu..
1- aise debate me panelist ki sankhya kam honi chahiye.
2- sabki bato ko sunane ki koshish kare.
3- pahle se apne mind me perception mat banaye..
aap bol rhe the poor ko v utna hi tax dena padega aur rich man ko v utna hi dena padega.aap mujhe bataye koi agar hum saman( soap, cloth,petrol etc) kharidte hai tab v poor ko v utna me hi milta hai jitna ki rich ko..aur usme tax include rhta hai..
agar naya system aayrga to kewal receiving transaction pe tax lagega..aur ye sare tax khattam ho jayenge..
man lijiye koi apne bete k account me paise dale.. aur waha pe 2% tax cut gaya..ab agar uska beta wahi paisa nikal k market se kuch saman kharidta hai to ab use koi tax nhi dena padega chuki saman pe koi tax lagega hi nhi..
ye tha aapke dono dout ka answer..
waise mujhe is naye system k bare me kuch malum nhi hai..mai kewal aapke dout clear karne ki koshish kar rha tha..
NAMASKAR..
ravish, baba k ek statement k karan aapko tax system me dimag khapana pad raha hai......pichhle do prime time me pahli baar aisa laga ki aapko koi sun hi nahi raha tha......ab baba ko kaun bataye ki bahut jyada bolna achha nahi hota......
ReplyDeletesabne itna kuchh likha hai...plz ek reply to kijiye...
aapki fan...amrita
आप सबका कमेंट पढ़ता रहता हूँ । एक शो को कितनी नज़र से आप देखते हैं । हैरान रह जाता हूँ । उम्मीद है आप लोग भी सारे कमेंट को पढ़ते होंगे ।
ReplyDeleteसोचने को विवश करता नारा।
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteहै कैसे इनको ओढ़ाया,
ReplyDeleteमंडेला का चोला ।
ये देख के चौटाला की,
कुर्सी का मन भी डोला ।।
Maaf kijiyega par fir kahuga ki ye Transaction Tax wala concept bilkul bekar hai. Apne show jarur kiya, mere hisab se aapke aur hamare time ki barbadi thi. Ravish ke show ki kuch khasiyat hai, issues jo yaha uthte hai wo wakai me kuch ahmiyat rakhte hai. Phir bhi apne kiya, to shayad yahi soch ke kiya ho, is issue ke khokhale pan ko jara jana jaye.
ReplyDeletenet ne aur aapne sabko intellectual bana diya hai......
ReplyDeletethank u so much...
सर आपने तो दिल पे ले लिया टैक्स को... काल्पनिक बातो से दूर रहिये... इतना तो बीजेपी भी न सोची होगी अभी तलक.. कमेटी भूल जाईये.. जो बीजेपी खुद सत्ता में होकर अपने बुनियादी मुद्दे मंदिर, ३७० पर कुछ नहीं कर सकी वो इतने जटिल टैक्स सिस्टम की ओर नज़र भी न डालने की, छेड़ना तो दूर की बात है..
ReplyDeleteकिसीको क्या मिला ? बाबाजी का ठुल्लू!!
बड़ी निराशा हुई आपके पैनल के सवालो से बाबा से.. बिना देश की जटिलताओं को समझे बिना बाजार के रिश्ते समझे कोई कुछ भी बोल रहा और आप रोक नही पा रहे इतने बड़े अर्थशास्त्री होकर भी.. उम्मीद करता हूँ ऐसी बहस से आप भविष्य में बचेंगे..
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletebahut maaje hain TV media ke khadkarapp jaise intelligent ke ,,kabhi Babanomics, kabhi ball e bidlan,kabhi Bhukkal Nawab ,kabhi Rahul ki Maldives yatra ,kabhi Modi Saheb ki chai aur har waqt AAP
ReplyDeleteHi Ravish,
ReplyDeleteI am one consistent follower of your blog and show.
Having said that, this is only the second time am adding a comment on your blog. As for rest of the times, I only enjoy listening to you and reading your blogs and have never felt the need to comment coz, when am listening to you or reading your blog, I feel as if am actually communicating to you.
So much for the emotions :). As far as the 'taxation' topic is concerned, I completely agree with what Mr. Saurabh Raj has mentioned in his comments and I do feel that we should give this approach a serious thought. Even Ramdev Ji was open for suggestions (he did talk about some slabs), and for once it is good that we're discussing around this topic.
(and yes, am a big fan of yours. Will make my day if I see a comment from you after my comment; even a smiley would do :P)
रवीश भाई, वेबसाइट का पता रोमन मे लिखा कीजिये, ऐसे भी आजकल हिंदी चैनल ऐसे शब्द जिनका हिंदी अनुवाद काफी सहजता से उपलब्ध है वैसे शब्दो के लिए भी अँग्रेज़ी प्रयोग करते है। arthakranti.org सही पता है ना कि अर्थक्रांतिओरजी, कुछ चैनल पे तो AAP को आप लिखते है :) BJP के बदले बीजेपी चलता है लेकिन कभी-कभी मतलब ही बदल जाता है।
ReplyDeleteजो करे घोटाला वही कहलाये चौटाला
ReplyDeleteteacher भर्ती का घोटाला कर रखा है और बनने चले मंडेला
कमाल है सर
Ravishji :) not fair :O
ReplyDeleteNelson Mandela ने ख़ुदकुशी नहीं की इसका अफ़सोस है क्या आप(कर्त्रू वाचक एक वचन) को? :) :-p
चौटाला ने कुछ न किया हो,लेकिन किसानों व मज़दूर वर्ग के लिए काम अवश्य किये हैं । हज़ारों गाँव के बच्चों को नौकरियाँ दी । सरकार आपके द्वार प्रोग्राम के तहत ब्लॉक स्तर पर लोगों से रूबरू होते थे । बतौर वर्कर कई साल मेहनत की, विकलाँग होते हुए भी, हमेशा गाँव में लोगों के बीच रहे । सादा खानपान, कभी शराब व बीडी सिगरेट का सेवन नहीं किया, साधारण पहनावा । 19 महीने, ऐमरजैंसी के दौरान जेल में रहे... कुछ तो किया था ।
ReplyDelete